FBlog | Discover the Interesting on the Web

What Makes A Good Video Downloader

best video downloader post main picture
What Makes A Good Video Downloader

Video downloading is a frequent task performed by PC users. There are many reasons people download videos: some want to back up a favorite clip, others want to upload videos for watching on various devices and so on. If you search for “video downloader” in a search engine, you’ll surely get thousands of results. And the truth is that the first 20-30 results are the most likely to provide you the tool you need to do the job. And isn’t that what really matters?

On the one hand, yes, because the video you wanted is downloaded and the problem is solved. On the other hand, there’s more to a really good video downloader than just being able to grab clips.

SEE ALSO: Step-by-Step Guide on Video Downloading

We determined there are 7 key features that make for a great video downloader:

  1. pricing
  2. setup
  3. easy-to-use interface
  4. number of supported sites
  5. download speed
  6. variety of output options
  7. support and troubleshooting.

We then compared the most popular video downloaders on the basis of these criteria:

  1. Free YTD Downloader (youtubedownloader.com)
  2. YouTube Downloader (Freemake)
  3. Keepvid.com
  4. aTube Catcher (atube.me)
  5. SaveFrom (savefrom.net).

View the comparison results and the winner below.


All the five tools on the list are free and ad-supported. Free YouTube Downloader, Freemake Video Downloader, SaveFrom Download Helper, and aTubeCatcher contain advertising offers within the installation and KeepVid shows ads on the site.

youtube downloader adsAnother example:

video downloader ads

The reason behind advertising is clear: software developers need funds to maintain and update even the most unsophisticated software. If you don’t want to support the project, you may easily opt out. Just click “I do not accept” or uncheck all the advertising offers.


Freemake Video Downloader, Free YTD Downloader, and aTubeCatcher are desktop software for Windows OS. KeepVid is an online tool, which means that you can use it without installing
anything to your PC. However, in most video download cases it requires a special extension and userscript, see here:


SaveFrom also recommends you install the Download Helper extension. So in all 5 instances there is some kind of installation process, either to your computer hard drive or to the browser. So all of the profiled tools in the same ready-to-use position.


It’s hard to judge. Still, we think that images speak louder than words. Lets’ have a look at the 5 interfaces.


Free YTD Downloader


Freemake Video Downloader

KeepVid interface


aTubeCatcher interface


savefrom interface


For most users, it’s a pleasure to see the minimalist approach to interface development, since no one has the time or desire to puzzle out pseudo-important buttons, menus, links, or icons. As such the Freemake Video Downloader, Free YTD Downloader, and SaveFrom interfaces seem to be the clearest, most logical, and most self-explanatory. As for visual appeal (I think you’ll agree with me ;)), Freemake Video Downloader has no equal on the above list.

Supported video sites

YouTube is the most popular video download destination, encompassing 99% of online video demand. However, it’s always a pleasure to know that software developers care about other sites as well. For instance, I love downloading Dailymotion videos but sometimes it’s a real problem finding a good video downloader that supporting this website. See the “supported video portals” details in the table below:

supported websites

Freemake Video Downloader seems to be the leader for the number of supported sites. Next comes KeepVid and SaveFrom.

Download speed

In order not to sound proofless, I chose three different videos and measured the time needed to download them as-is.

Video downloader speed

As the results show, almost all tools are pretty fast when it comes to downloading short videos (1-3 minutes). Still, if you want to rip long movies, online shows or full episodes you’re better off choosing Freemake Video Downloader, as it proves itself to be the speediest video downloader. Next comes aTube Catcher and SaveFrom tools.

Output options

Sometimes it’s necessary to convert an online video to a specific format or resolution in order to make it playable on a mobile phone, DVD player or music gadget. As such we can’t do without re-encoding. So let’s explore output video/audio formats and supported devices offered by the downloaders under analysis.

video download output

As you can see, the majority of the video downloaders here support all possible online video qualities: from 4K to 144p. But while almost all the tools do both video downloading and conversion, Freemake Video Downloader, and aTubeCatcher provide more output options.

SEE ALSO: What makes the Best DVD Ripper?

Support and troubleshooting

YouTube and other sites often change their video hosting algorithms in order to prevent video downloading. So from time to time almost all video downloaders stop working. In such cases, it may take up to several weeks for developers to notice and fix the problem.
SEE ALSO: YouTube to MP3 not Working?

Have a look at what technical support options the developers of popular video downloaders provide:

video downloader support

The Freemake Video Downloader developers seem to be the most responsive to this problem. They claim that any video download issues are fixed within 24 hours. They collect user tickets on their support portal and Facebook fan page and technical support is totally free. Plus, on the Freemake website there’s a large section of how-to’s and FAQs.

Bottom line

Each program has its upside. For example KeepVid and SaveFrom let you download videos without installing anything to your PC and aTubeCatcher offers dozens of output video options. Still, the comparison results show that Freemake Video Downloader is the undisputed leader of the pack with all the necessary download options, an intuitive interface and the ability to rip videos faster than all the other tools.